Maximizing Business Assets: What to Do with an Unneeded Life Insurance Policy

Many businesses purchase life insurance policies to mitigate financial risks associated with key personnel or to fund buy-sell agreements between partners. These policies are invaluable when they’re needed, ensuring that a company can continue operations or complete an ownership transition without financial strain.

But what happens when a policy is no longer necessary? Maybe a key employee has retired, the ownership structure has changed, or the business itself has evolved beyond the original need for coverage. When that happens, business owners face a decision: What’s the best way to handle an outdated life insurance policy?

Rather than simply letting the policy lapse and losing the years of premiums invested, businesses have several options. Depending on financial goals, tax considerations, and the policy type, a company may choose to:

• Maintain the policy for a different purpose
• Surrender it for its cash value
• Exchange it for a different insurance product
• Use it as collateral for a loan
• Sell it through a life settlement
• Transfer it to the insured individual for personal planning

At Transcend Advisor Group, we help businesses navigate these choices, ensuring they maximize the value of their life insurance assets. Whether you’re looking to free up capital, reduce expenses, or repurpose coverage for a different business strategy, we provide guidance tailored to your company’s needs. Let’s explore the various ways you can manage an unneeded business life insurance policy and how each option can impact your financial outlook.

Option 1: Repurpose the Policy for a New Business Need

Just because the policy’s original purpose no longer applies doesn’t mean it has to be discarded. A business may find that the coverage can be repurposed for a different risk or financial goal.

For example:

• A policy originally purchased for a buy-sell agreement could instead be used for business continuity or estate equalization.
• A business could use the policy’s cash value as a financial reserve or an investment vehicle within a corporate financial strategy.

Keeping the policy can be a good option when the business still finds value in maintaining coverage or leveraging its cash value.

Option 2: Transfer the Policy to the Insured for Personal Planning

If the insured executive or employee is still living, transferring the policy to them for personal use may be a tax-efficient way to remove it from the company’s books while still preserving its value.

Why would this make sense?

• The insured may wish to keep the coverage for their own estate planning, retirement, or legacy goals.
• The business can negotiate the terms of the transfer – whether selling it to the individual at a fair market value or gifting it as part of a compensation package.
• The executive can assume responsibility for the premiums and use the policy for family protection, wealth transfer, or charitable giving.

This strategy works well when the insured has an ongoing need for personal coverage, and the business is willing to offload the cost while keeping the value in trusted hands.

Option 3: Surrender the Policy for Cash Value

For businesses looking for a simple exit, surrendering the policy back to the insurer is an option. The insurance company will pay the cash surrender value, which represents the policy’s accumulated cash minus any surrender charges.

While this is the most straightforward approach, it’s not always the most financially rewarding. Cash surrender values are typically much lower than the policy’s potential market value, meaning the business may be leaving money on the table.

Before surrendering a policy, it’s worth evaluating alternative strategies that could yield a higher return.

Option 4: Exchange the Policy for a New Insurance Product (1035 Exchange)

If the business still wants insurance coverage but no longer needs the existing policy, a 1035 exchange allows for the transfer of cash value into a new policy- without triggering a taxable event.

This strategy may be useful if:

• The company needs a different type of insurance (e.g., converting a whole life policy into an annuity).
• The existing policy is underperforming, and a better alternative is available.
• The insured’s health has changed, and a different policy structure may offer better financial benefits.

A 1035 exchange can help businesses make a tax-efficient shift while maintaining coverage that better aligns with current needs.

Option 5: Use the Policy as Collateral for a Loan

If the policy has significant cash value, the business may be able to borrow against it instead of liquidating it. Many lenders allow businesses to use a life insurance policy as loan collateral, providing liquidity without fully surrendering or selling the policy.

Benefits of this strategy:

• Access to business capital without giving up the policy
• The business retains future death benefit value
• Interest rates may be lower than traditional business loans

This option makes sense for businesses that need short-term liquidity but want to keep the policy in place.

Option 6: Sell the Policy Through a Life Settlement

For policies that no longer serve a business purpose, a life settlement can be a powerful financial move. This allows the business to sell the policy to an institutional investor for an amount greater than the cash surrender value but less than the death benefit.

Why consider a life settlement?

• Larger payouts (typically 3 to 5 times more than the surrender value)
• Immediate cash infusion for business reinvestment, debt reduction, or other priorities
• Eliminates ongoing premium payments that no longer serve the company

While not all policies qualify, those with insured individuals over age 65 with moderate health impairments tend to have the highest market value.

At Transcend, we help businesses evaluate their policy’s potential and navigate the life settlement process to secure the best possible return.

Choosing the Right Path for Your Business

Outdated business life insurance policies don’t have to be wasted or written off as sunk costs. Instead, businesses can approach them strategically – whether by transferring the policy to the insured, repurposing it for a new use, or unlocking value through a sale or exchange.

At Transcend, we specialize in helping businesses make informed decisions about their life insurance assets. Whether you need guidance on evaluating your policy’s worth, transferring ownership, or exploring the life settlement market, we’re here to ensure you maximize your policy’s financial potential.

Don’t let an old policy become a forgotten liability – turn it into an opportunity. Contact us today to explore your options and make the most of your business’s insurance assets.

LET’S GET STARTED